Whitmer Pizza

Great pizza! We traveled to Amish country from Columbus, OH and this place happened to be around the corner from where we were staying. Their pizza sauce is really good! It reminds me of Romeo's pizza back home. Highly recommend. We also had the chicken dinner with potato wedges and roll for dinner and it was good as well. The four piece comes with a large breast, a medium breast, wing, and drumstick. Recommend trying this restaurant if you're in the area!

This is a great little restaurant inside an even better old-time grocery. We called for a pizza at 15 minutes to close on a Friday, and the lovely lady was more than friendly. She took my order, it was ready before closing, and she even said that my order looked so good that she wanted to try one (chicken bacon ranch with garlic sauce). I asked for parmesan cheese to go (which they don't have) and the staff dug around and found a shaker in the fridge and put some on the pizza for me. Service above and beyond at closing time!!